"April closed out our spring season with 11 sales and a clear message: pricing discipline is everything right now. The homes that came to market priced correctly closed in under 50 days and at 95 to 99 percent of ask. The ones chasing numbers from two years ago sat for months and eventually sold for far less than if they had priced right from day one. For buyers, end-of-season timing and an appraisal gap on the right property created real opportunity, and that is exactly the scenario we positioned our clients to capture at 204 Gulf Boulevard."
STR-Eligible Properties Only
This report covers single-family homes in Indian Rocks Beach that qualify for short-term rental use under Indian Rocks Beach Ordinance 2023-02, which permits nightly rentals with no minimum stay. It does not include all IRB residential sales. Closed data is April 2026. Active and pending inventory reflects the full current market as of May 12, 2026. This is the first in a monthly series; month-over-month comparisons begin with the June 2026 report.
How the Month Closed
Eleven single-family STR-eligible homes closed in Indian Rocks Beach in April. The active market heading into summer is broader than it may appear, with 27 STR-eligible listings carrying a median ask of $1,475,000, nearly double the $830,000 median that buyers actually paid in April.
Source: StellarMLS. Closed data: STR-eligible single-family properties, Indian Rocks Beach FL, April 1-30, 2026. Active and pending as of May 12, 2026.
27 Active Listings and a $645,000 Price Gap
The most important number in this report is not the median sale price. It is the distance between what sellers are asking and what buyers are paying. With 27 active listings at a median ask of $1,475,000 and April closings settling at a median of $830,000, there is a $645,000 gap at the midpoint of the market. That gap is where deals are made, or are not made at all.
Median Ask vs. Median Sale: The Price Discovery Gap
Of the 27 active listings, ten have been on the market more than 120 days. The longest-sitting active, 724 Gulf Blvd, has been listed 752 days. Multiple active sellers have already cut from their original list price and are still waiting for a buyer.
Source: StellarMLS as of May 12, 2026.
Original List Price to Sale Price: What Overpricing Actually Costs
The standard sold-to-list ratio uses the final list price, which hides how much a seller actually lost compared to their original ask. The table below shows every April closing with original list price, final sale price, and true SP/OLP ratio sorted by performance. The pattern is unmistakable.
What the data proves: Every home that achieved 94 percent or more of its original list price closed in 46 days or fewer. Every home that sat 200 or more days sold at 86 percent or less of original ask, losing tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars compared to what correct pricing from day one would have returned.
| Address | Original List | Sale Price | SP / OLP | DOM | Pool |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 404 Maxwell Pl | $810,000 | $800,000 | 99% | 45 days | Yes |
| 322 La Hacienda Dr | $850,000 | $830,000 | 98% | 29 days | No |
| 1210 Bay Pine Blvd | $995,000 | $987,500 | 99% | 272 days | No |
| 322 10th Ave | $1,370,000 | $1,300,000 | 95% | 8 days | No |
| 387 12th Ave | $1,695,555 | $1,595,000 | 94% | 46 days | Yes |
| 306 12th Ave | $475,000 | $435,000 | 92% | 38 days | No |
| 204 Gulf Blvd | $2,100,000 | $1,797,500 | 86% | 90 days | Yes |
| 1214 Bay Shore Blvd | $499,999 | $430,000 | 86% | 248 days | No |
| 122 10th Ave | $549,000 | $410,000 | 75% | 343 days | No |
| 119 13th Ave | $849,900 | $530,000 | 62% | 225 days | No |
| 433 20th Ave ⓘ see note | $1,890,000 | $1,000,000 | 53% | 80 days | Yes |
Note on 433 20th Ave: This sale at 53% of original list reflects a seller who entered at $1,890,000 for a 2-bedroom, 1-bath, 1,264 sq ft 1957-built home. The price did not reflect post-Hurricane Helene market reality or the property's size and bedroom count. The $1,000,000 final sale is consistent with what the market will pay for a pool home of this profile. Excluding this outlier, the remaining 10 closings had a median SP/OLP of 92%.
Note on 204 Gulf Blvd: This transaction, representing our buyer, closed at 86% of original list due to an appraisal gap on a highly differentiated Gulf-side property with limited direct comparables. The buyer secured the highest-priced single-family closing of the month at a price that positions them well for future equity and STR performance. This reflects skilled negotiation where fewer buyers compete at the top tier, not a broad market weakness signal.
Source: StellarMLS. OLP = Original List Price as recorded in MLS at initial listing. STR-eligible single-family properties, Indian Rocks Beach FL, closed April 2026.
How Pool Homes Performed in April
Four of the 11 April closings were pool homes. In the IRB STR market, a pool drives meaningful revenue: AirROI 2026 data shows average annual gross revenue of $64,338 across 846 active listings, with pool homes consistently outperforming on ADR and occupancy. Of the 27 active listings, 15 include a pool, meaning pool supply is strong and correct pricing matters even more.
Pool Homes, 4 Closings (excl. outlier)
Non-Pool Homes, 7 Closings
Source: StellarMLS, April 2026. AirROI data: May 2025 to April 2026, 846 active IRB listings.
Long-Sitting and Already-Reduced Active Listings
Several active listings have been on the market well over 100 days and have already taken price cuts. These are the properties where the overpricing lesson from April closings is playing out in real time for sellers still waiting.
Active Listings with 120+ Days on Market or Price Reductions
Source: StellarMLS as of May 12, 2026.
10 Contracts Under Way
Ten properties are currently under contract, ranging from $460,000 to $6,750,000. Three of the 10 sat more than 200 days before going under contract, all with significant reductions from original ask. The data reinforces the same lesson as the April closings: the market will eventually clear overpriced properties, but sellers pay a steep price in both time and money.
| Address | OLP | Pending Price | DOM | Pool |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1507 Legion Ln, 2BR | $460,000 | $460,000 | 24 days | No |
| 310 12th Ave, 2BR | $679,000 | $679,000 | 3 days | No |
| 1211 Bay Pine Blvd, 3BR | $900,000 | $860,000 | 62 days | Yes |
| 960 Gulf Blvd #1, 2BR | $975,000 | $975,000 | 220 days | No |
| 118 10th Ave, 3BR | $1,395,000 | $1,300,000 | 65 days | No |
| 330 6th Ave, 5BR | $1,999,995 | $2,375,000 | 261 days | Yes |
| 540 20th Ave, 3BR | $2,950,000 | $2,950,000 | 5 days | Yes |
| 30 Gulf Blvd, 8BR | $4,750,000 | $4,490,000 | 78 days | No |
| 1522 Gulf Blvd, 4BR | $5,900,000 | $4,900,000 | 430 days | Yes |
| 2 Gulf Blvd, 5BR | $8,800,000 | $6,750,000 | 318 days | Yes |
Source: StellarMLS as of May 12, 2026. Pending prices shown, not final sale prices.
What April and the Current Inventory Tell Us Together
Eleven closings in April is healthy output for the end of the spring selling season on the Pinellas Gulf Beaches. But the fuller picture, 27 active listings with a median ask nearly double the April median close, tells a more nuanced story about where price discovery is still happening.
The market has a functioning sub-$1.5M tier where correctly priced homes move in under 50 days. It has a more contested $1.5M to $3M tier where sellers are still finding their footing post-Helene. And it has a luxury tier above $3M where deals are possible, as shown by the pending pipeline, but only after sellers accept significant reductions from original ask.
For STR investors evaluating an IRB purchase, the AirROI 2026 benchmark of $64,338 average annual gross revenue, $438 ADR, and 46.3% occupancy across 846 active listings provides the performance baseline. The Haydon SHORE™ STR Investment Framework evaluates the five factors that determine whether a specific property will outperform that baseline: Supply and Demand, Hosting and Rental Rules, Operating Economics, Risk and Resilience, and Experience and Earnings Potential.
"Twenty-seven active listings and a $645,000 gap between the median ask and what buyers actually paid in April tells you this market is doing its price discovery work in real time. For buyers who are patient and prepared, there is opportunity in that gap. For sellers still anchored to 2022 values, the closed data from April is the conversation we need to have before you hit the market."
Talk to the Gulf Beaches STR Specialist
Cyndee Haydon has closed 62 STR-friendly properties in the past five years and 150+ vacation rental transactions since 2005. She knows this market from the sand up.
Return to IRB STR Guide